Skip to content
Matterfile

About

Chris Hu

Debates, arguments, and the ideas behind them.

My name is Chris Hu, and I'm affiliated with Columbia University.

Matterfile collects arguments, debate cases, speech notes and excerpts. Some pieces are finished cases; others are working notes or sections of longer documents, and each one is labelled as such.

Where this material comes from

Much of what is here was written as preparation for debate rounds: cases for motions in "This House believes that…" or "This House supports…" form, arguments for the Proposition, Government or Opposition, and notes for a British Parliamentary round, including an Opposition extension and whip-style weighing at the end of the round.

Editor's note: Debate cases often argue an assigned side, so the pieces here are not necessarily the author's views.

What the pieces cover

  • Artificial intelligence and its risks: existential risk, the displacement of workers, bias, privacy and misinformation.
  • The military use of AI, including the arms race between the United States and China.
  • Social movements and political change in developing countries: what movements should campaign for, and what stands in their way.
  • Development and resource economics: mineral exports, sovereign debt and global supply chains.
  • Moral philosophy in debate: principle arguments, rights trade-offs, and the pull between utilitarian and deontological reasoning.
  • Education policy: how the school year is structured and who gains or loses from it.

How the arguments are built

Editor's summary, drawn from the published pieces rather than written by the author.

The pieces tend to follow the same habits. They look for the mechanism, not just the claim that something will happen but the reason it would. They compare against the other side's world rather than against a perfect one. They try to answer the strongest responses before they are made. And they weigh: by scale, by certainty, by timeframe, and by whether a harm can be undone once it happens.

On principle arguments in particular, the notes here take the view that a principle should be unique to the case rather than run just to have one, and that its intuition pump should be defended in advance, because that is usually where opponents will attack it.

Get in touch

You can find me on LinkedIn.