Skip to content
Matterfile
The archive

Arguments

Cases, speech notes and excerpts, most of them written for debate rounds. Debate cases often argue an assigned side, so these are not necessarily the author’s views.

  1. ArgumentPolitics, Global Development12 min read

    Attitudes Before Laws: How Progressive Movements in Developing Countries Should Campaign

    An Opposition case on whether progressive movements in developing countries should campaign for legal change or attitudinal change. It argues that changing attitudes is both better (laws follow attitudes and go unenforced without social buy-in) and easier (governments are often corrupt, captured and coalition-bound, while individuals can be persuaded).

  2. ArgumentTechnology & AI, Economics, Politics21 min read

    AI Does, or Will Do, More Harm Than Good

    A Proposition case arguing that AI does or will do more harm than good, framed as a normative debate rather than a policy debate about banning AI. It makes five arguments: existential risk, labour-market displacement and inequality, threats to democracy and escalation of conflict, structural bias against marginalized groups, and mass invasions of privacy.

  3. Case notesGlobal Development, Economics7 min read

    Against Banning Africa's Unprocessed Mineral Exports

    Opposition speech notes from a British Parliamentary round on whether African countries should ban the export of unprocessed mineral ores. They argue that a ban would raise world mineral prices, hurting poor consumers and climate goals worldwide, and cut off export revenue that African governments need for debt, budgets, technology imports and infrastructure. The notes then weigh both sides on scale, certainty and timeframe.

  4. ExcerptEthics & Debate Method5 min read

    How to Build a Principle Argument

    A six-step method for building principle arguments in debate: choose the independent moral, explain why it matters to the actor, show the opponents' violation, weigh it against competing morals, supply an intuition pump, and justify that intuition pump as analogous. This excerpt is the opening section of a longer study guide.

  5. ArgumentEducation4 min read

    A Four-Day School Week, With No Summer Vacation

    A Proposition case for a four-day school week whose model removes summer vacation, so students learn the same total material. Its single argument is that summer vacation harms learning through forgetting, a widening gap between richer and poorer students, and physical and mental harms to children.

  6. Case notesTechnology & AI, Politics5 min read

    American Frontier AI Firms Should Cease All Cooperation With the US Military

    Government-side notes arguing that American frontier AI firms should stop cooperating with the US military. Four arguments: frontier AI lowers the cost of intervention and removes human hesitation, it speeds up a US–China arms race and regulatory capture, it pulls research away from socially productive uses, and it weakens democratic checks.