A Four-Day School Week, With No Summer Vacation
A Proposition case for a four-day school week whose model removes summer vacation, so students learn the same total material. Its single argument is that summer vacation harms learning through forgetting, a widening gap between richer and poorer students, and physical and mental harms to children.
- Author
- Chris Hu
- Side:
- Proposition
- Length
- 4 min read
Motion
This house supports a four day school week
Model
On either side of the house, kids still have to learn the same amount of material to graduate. School curriculum is designed to prepare you for life, and the requisite skills students eventually obtain are the same on either side. To reconcile this, the model we support is a four-day school week but with no summer vacation.
Argument: Summer vacation is terrible for learning
Sub A: Information atrophy
When people stop reinforcing concepts learnt at regular intervals, they forget knowledge and have to relearn them. This is counterproductive.
Impact:
- Students learn less content on the net. This is because teachers have to spend extensive time reviewing previously learned material because knowledge builds upon one another. If you forget about functions, you can’t learn calculus.
- Due a limited resource and time of the teacher, students become cyclically neglected. There is strong stress and anxiety for students to catch up with forgotten material in a limited amount of time, so if they slack off or get overwhelmed, it becomes difficult to catch up in the long run without external help like tutoring. Importantly, spending 1 month to relearn old material takes up a lot of time that could have been spent to study new material, but that 1 month is also relatively short if you are relearning 6 months of material learnt earlier.
Sub B: Inequality
Research shows that more than half of the achievement gap between lower- and higher-income youth can be explained by unequal access to summer learning opportunities. This is because richer students in the summer still have access to human and resource capital to improve their academic performances while there is an asymmetry of resources for poorer students.
On average, students lost about 30 percent of their school-year learning over the summer. Latino and black students tend to lose much more in the summer. This is because while alternatives like summer learning programs exist to help students retain and practice knowledge, only the richer people can afford summer schools.
Impacts:
- Low-income youth are less likely to graduate from high school or enter college. This is because of the mechanism college selects students based on whoever has a higher grade. When rich students always outcompete poorer students, they are more likely to be enrolled in limited spots provided by the university. This affects future employment because your employability depends on your education level, and this finally results in income gaps and the poor continue to be disenfranchised.
- Poorer students performing worst feeds into the narrative that poorer students are lazy and stupid. Historical justifications for eugenics and technocracy are that rich people are also smart and hard-working people. This stigma is usually self-internalized by the poorer students when classmates make fun of their grades, leading to bad mental health.
Sub C: Physical and mental harms
When school is not in the way to intervene in children, they are exposed to physical and mental risks that are destructive.
Before talking about those harms, two pieces of framing:
- Most parents, under the rise and grind culture now, stick to rigid time schedules and will not have time to look over their children during summer break.
- Children are naturally immature. Their pre-frontal cortex development is incomplete, and we in general make terrible risk and reward calculus that are impulsive. The purpose of school is to teach us to develop mature behaviours as a habit and a second nature, and habit only builds with continuous effort to fixate on it.
First on the physical:
- Most children—particularly children at high risk of obesity—gain weight more rapidly when they are out of school during summer break. This is because meals are not eaten in a structured routine.
- Children are extremely sedentary, usually sitting in front of a screen every day in the summer. Parents can’t intervene because of busy schedules.
- Children forget about disciplinary habits developed during school years, ie waking up early and completing tasks online. These are important skills that need years to grapple with. When you have no responsibility, you become unhealthy and sick.
Second on the mental:
- Children are more likely to get depression. Summer vacation is social isolation for many students because school is a setting that forcefully makes kids talk to one another and is a medium for collaboration. When there isn’t such a forced mechanism and an alternative is to scroll through reels in your bedroom, many kids develop depression and terrible mental health. Uniquely, in the summer, kids can’t find any support mechanism as teachers and guidance are not available.
- Summer break is just really boring because without the school making us learn or work on something, our inertia never takes the initiative.
Editor’s note: The figures in Sub B and the empirical claims in Sub C appear without citations in the original notes.