Skip to content
Matterfile

How to Build a Principle Argument

A six-step method for building principle arguments in debate: choose the independent moral, explain why it matters to the actor, show the opponents' violation, weigh it against competing morals, supply an intuition pump, and justify that intuition pump as analogous. This excerpt is the opening section of a longer study guide.

Author
Chris Hu
Length
5 min read

Excerpt. This is a section of a longer document, not the complete piece.

Excerpt: the opening section of a longer set of notes on principle arguments. Later reference sections are not included here.

Principle arguments are irreducible and overriding normativity that supersedes practical impacts. They can be a really powerful tool in debating.

Step 1: Independent Moral

In this part, you simply decide which independent moral you are defending. This can be an obligation, a right, or an entire moral system depending on the round. You can think of this as the tagline for your principle.

Examples of common independent morals in debate:

  • Parent/Child obligation, reparative obligation, reciprocity, fiduciary obligation, etc.
  • Right to life, self-determination, self-defense, privacy, security, freedom from persecution (religion, sexuality, race, etc.), to autonomy.
  • Util, deontology (you’re probably not using any others).

Deontology is circumstantial: Right to defense is often deontologically defended but it's intuitive, i.e. there are 6 guys pointing guns at me and I shot 1 of the 6, and the other 5 shot me. In most circumstances, people are not Jason Statham and their act of defense does not lead to utilitarian goods.

Step 2: Significance of the Moral to the Actor

Notice that a moral exists because it is significant to an actor. The idea of objective morality is pretty defunct especially from a utilitarian lens; the wrongs are concluded aggregatively--murder is wrong because most people believe that living is good.

Explain why the moral you are defending is important. What makes it imperative to defend; why is it valuable to the stakeholder(s) in the round?

If the moral itself is your tagline, this is the warrant of your principle. The violation of your principle will always be the impact, so the warrant is why we should care about that violation.

Ex: Right to self-determination exists because the state maintains and exerts a monopoly of violence over its citizens; while necessary to a functional society, it is only legitimate insofar as citizens exert control over the limitations and applications of that violence.

Ex: Fiduciary responsibility exists because investors have taken on significant personal risk to allow for a company’s survival, creating a reciprocal moral obligation of that company to not take advantage & to minimize that risk.

Note that implicit in fiduciary obligation is the legitimacy of a reciprocal obligation-this is often the case: the more specific an obligation is, the higher likelihood that it carries implied or assumed moral obligations or systems which support it.

Recognizing this is crucial because it gives us both opportunities to attack principles that may not be clear at first glance, and it also gives us a preemptive awareness of how our own principle may be attacked. For example, when weighing against the above fiduciary responsibility I might say that fiduciary responsibility is based on a reciprocal obligation that comes from a utilitarian model, where it is presumed that good can be optimized if parties which interact with one another treat each other with mutual care. However, the fiduciary responsibility ignores that both the company and its investors interact indirectly but powerfully with the average consumer. If the premise of the responsibility is one of mutual care to optimize good, then it is sensible that there are times a company should be able to prioritize its consumers over its investors in cases where failure to do so would induce greater harm.

If I knew this route of attack was possible, I can find a response easier—where I can say that without the investors, the product never would have reached the consumers to begin with. This matters because fiduciary responsibility is the safety net that encourages investment in the first place; if that safety net is compromised all potential investors in any business immediately feel less secure in their potential investment. This means that many startups never get off the ground-especially those with high startup costs or high volatility, which is often the case for services which provide a significant public good.

Step 3: Violation

Explain why the advocacy of your opponents violates your independent morals.

This is the impact of your principled case-obviously, if they don’t violate the moral then your principle is useless.

This calls attention to a significant and common problem in the execution of moral arguments in debate-debaters will often run a principle just to have one, without considering if that principle is unique to their case.

Step 4: Comparative Weighing

It is extremely rare that you’ll find a debate where your opponents’ advocacy is simply immoral; usually, there is a debate to be had about the rights trade-off.

  • Privacy vs. Security
  • Self-Determination vs. Security
  • Autonomy vs. Public Health (Utilitarianism)
  • Autonomy vs. Religious Freedoms

You’ll need to explain why your independent moral is the most important one in the round, and why it is thus justifiable to trade-off with whatever moral your opponents defend.

Note that your opponents may not always be explicit about defending an independent moral, but if they’re trying to outweigh your principle with material harm, the significance of those material harms will be rooted in some independent moral. If you can identify it, you can weigh against it more easily.

Some examples of reasons to value one independent moral over another:

  • One moral is a-priori (the other moral is logically dependent on it).

    Ex: The right to life is a-priori to the right to self-determination.

  • Many morals are based on util, so regular weighing metrics can also apply.

    Ex: Irreversibility, Certainty (Rule-Utilitarianism), Magnitude (Often articulated as vulnerability)

  • Some morals are based on deontology & explaining why something can be good without being utile is important.

    Ex: The right to Self-Defense

Note also that rights are sometimes traded off in a gradient tied to personal responsibility & risk.

Ex: Police are granted a capacity to violate certain aspects of your privacy/autonomy, but only on the condition that you risk a violation of the competing right. A police officer cannot pull you over or detain you without reasonable suspicion of a violation of the law, they cannot search your person or your property without a warrant in many cases/countries, and they cannot (theoretically) harm you in many countries unless doing so is the only way to prevent you from doing harm to others. The greater a risk you present to security (the competing right) the greater the degree to which you sacrifice your personal right to autonomy.

Step 5: Intuition Pump for the Weighing

Moral imperatives, like emotional impacts, are often nebulous and hard to prove. An intuition pump which shows another area in which your moral calculus is used & accepted goes a long way towards winning that all-important benefit of the doubt.

Ex: When considering trading off personal freedoms because of the cost to public health/the safety of others, people often reference the ban on smoking in indoor public spaces. When considering trading off an individual's autonomy for their own safety, people will often reference seatbelt laws

Step 6: Justify the Intuition

Explain why the example you used as your intuition pump is analogous to the context in which you’re applying it. The intuition pump is often where debaters will target your principle, by explaining why that situation is different because it’s the weakest part of the principle by nature of being an example. For that reason, it’s worth protecting preemptively.